Skip to content
Clean Network Amsterdam

Constitutional Vote Loss Leaves Italy's Meloni Looking More Exposed.

Giorgia Meloni addressing the vote outcome
Giorgia Meloni stated the referendum was a lost opportunity to update Italy.

Italy's Premier Giorgia Meloni has suffered a loss in a pivotal constitutional referendum, which ultimately became a wider judgment on her leadership.

The final tally assigned approximately 54% to the "Against" side and 46% to the "Yes" vote that PM Meloni had strongly backed.

"The electorate have voted with clarity," the Prime Minister commented in a video message, posted before all votes were tallied. "I will respect their decision, but I regret a lost chance to revitalize the nation."

This represents the initial significant defeat for PM Meloni and her conservative government, which has presided over a unusual period of political stability for Italy. Political opponents are celebrating the outcome as a telling signal that voters are seeking change, with a general election expected next year.

Ballot Tally

When the balloting period ended on Monday afternoon, early exit polls showed the "No" vote leading by a slim gap. Yet, that lead grew to a considerable one as the tallying continued.

In spite of the technical question on the voting slip, voter turnout was close to 60%. A robust turnout had been generally predicted to aid the administration, but it proved insufficient to tip the overall result.

The Defeated Proposal

The proposed change that voters voted against would have entrenched a clear split between the judiciary and public prosecutors into the constitution. It also proposed independent entities to govern them and a novel ethics tribunal.

The administration argued the reform was critical to strengthening the separation of powers. The opposition countered that it would upset a long-established system of checks and balances put in place following the overthrow of the fascist regime, and boost partisan control over the legal system.

Many Italians found it difficult to grasp the nuances – maybe a explanation lapse by Team Meloni – and the vote soon turned into a plebiscite on her near-record three and a half years in power.

Celebrations by opposition voters
The winning camp gathered to observe their triumph.

A Tough Backdrop

The setback fell in a trying time. The Prime Minister is a key partner of ex-US President Donald Trump, whose standing has declined in Italy, along with approval of his approach on the war in Gaza.

Moreover, with Italy's economy sluggish, many people are increasingly concerned about the crisis's impact on energy costs and overall inflation.

Consequences

Meloni had always ruled out resigning, regardless of the result. This is unlike the decision of former PM Matteo Renzi in 2016, who initiated his own similar vote as prime minister and stepped down after being defeated.

"The vote is not about me, but about the judicial system," Meloni had argued ahead of the poll.

When the outcome was apparent, Renzi opined that her administration had now lost its "magic touch" and needed to pay closer attention to public sentiment. "Losing and walking out whistling just isn't an option," he remarked to Italian radio.

If the result had been positive almost certainly encouraged her to chase other reform goals, including a proposal to introduce direct elections for the prime minister.

On the contrary, rival PD head Elly Schlein declared that Meloni's defeat proved "there is an alternative to this administration" before next year's national vote.

This loss has taken some of the shine off the government and Meloni herself, previously the the unyielding leader of Italian politics, has been made seeming weaker.

About the author

Adam Ayala

Lena van der Berg is a Dutch cybersecurity journalist and advocate for digital rights, covering privacy and tech policy.

Clean Network Amsterdam

Type to search articles.